
On 10 September 2026, Korea’s Patent Court decided case 2025 Heo 10503 concerning a registered mark used in a different lettering and colour scheme. It separately compared the registered DUOLASH composite, the DUAL sign actually used and another trader’s DUO sign when examining cancellation for improper use.
Registration does not protect every subsequent variation. The important questions were how much the revised sign approached the other trader’s branding, whether confusion about commercial origin increased and whether the proprietor knew of that sign.
Three different signs had to be identified
Korean Trademark Registration No. 1947575 combined a device on the left with DUOLASH on the right and Korean wording meaning “Duo eyelashes” underneath. Filed on 23 December 2019 and registered on 13 December 2022, it covered artificial eyelashes and adhesive for fixing artificial eyelashes.

The sign actually used on adhesive products and website advertisements, referred to as use mark 1, was DUAL in bold pink capitals. The device, LASH and Korean wording were omitted, while lettering, typeface and colour changed. Actual-use branding means the sign used in business, rather than its representation on the register.

Ardell International, Inc., which sought cancellation, used DUO for eyelash adhesive and related goods in Korea. The court concentrated on its target mark 3: the bold pink DUO lettering. That was the competing sign against which the actual DUAL use was assessed.

Website advertising constituted trademark use
Around May 2023, the defendant posted photographs, product names and prices of adhesive bearing use mark 1 on the website of a company the defendant represented. Advertising continued, and the court found that use persisted at least until 15 June 2026.
The court treated displaying and publicising the mark in advertisements for goods as trademark use under the former Korean Trademark Act applied in the judgment. The advertised eyelash adhesive was identical to adhesive within the registration’s designated goods.
The finding rested on concrete online advertisements combining product photographs, names and prices. For online businesses, the particular branding and presentation used to advertise a product can therefore become material evidence of use.
Why DUAL came closer to DUO
Although the endings AL and O differed, both signs began with DU and used bold pink capital lettering with similar typefaces and colours. In Korean pronunciation, both were two-syllable expressions beginning with the same sound; the different final sounds did not remove their aural similarity.
Their meanings also overlapped: DUAL conveyed something double, while DUO meant a pair or two-person group. The court considered appearance, pronunciation and meaning together rather than deciding the issue from a single letter sequence.

The defendant placed DUAL in a position and size similar to DUO on the claimant’s product, with comparable explanatory text and a pink diagonal panel on the right. Those presentation choices combined with the similar signs to make the overall packages considerably alike.
Turquoise Korean wording, certification markings and differences in smaller text and devices did not dispel the concern. The prominent pink DUAL sign and the combined colour, size, position and surrounding pattern mattered; pale tubes and small explanatory text were not, by themselves, sufficient grounds for confusion.
The court also considered target mark 3’s recognition in Korea: sales in 2018, its ranking within the product range, press and online exposure, and continuing DUO adhesive sales. Some sales figures covered a brand or product group rather than that particular mark alone. The court assessed them alongside the specific product’s distribution and ranking.
The relationship with the registered mark required a separate analysis
Improper-use cancellation does not end with a comparison against the competing sign. The court also compared the registration with DUAL and acknowledged that their elements, arrangement, typeface and colours made their appearances difficult to regard as similar.
LASH and the Korean word for eyelashes were weakly distinctive because they described the goods or their purpose. DUO and its Korean transliteration, however, did not directly describe the goods’ particular characteristics and could be perceived separately. They were dominant elements independently indicating commercial origin.
DUAL retained phonetic and conceptual similarities to those dominant elements while its typeface and colour moved towards the claimant’s DUO. Because the changes increased the likelihood of origin confusion relative to use of the mark as registered, the court treated them as use of a similar mark under Article 119(1)(1) of Korea’s Trademark Act.
That assessment is independent of the identity standard used in non-use cancellation proceedings. The improper-use provision addresses alterations that move a registered mark towards another trader’s sign and exploit its goodwill; its purpose therefore informs the comparison.
An unsuccessful opposition still mattered to intent
Ardell had opposed the application on 26 April 2021, relying on previously used DUO signs. On 12 December 2022, the Korean Intellectual Property Office rejected the opposition because it could not conclude that the application imitated those marks or involved an improper purpose. That result did not decide the lawfulness of later modified use.
From the timing and substance of the opposition, the court found that the defendant knew, at the latest around that decision, that the claimant used several DUO signs for adhesive and related products. Although those earlier signs differed from target mark 3 in colour or details, all prominently displayed DUO.
Recognition in the Korean trade and the defendant’s subsequent adoption of a similar presentation supported knowledge of target mark 3 when use mark 1 was used. The court therefore found intentional improper use. The competing mark need not necessarily qualify as well known or famous for this cancellation ground to arise.
The court annulled the decision dismissing cancellation
On 26 June 2025, the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) dismissed the cancellation petition, relying in part on dissimilarity between the registered and actual-use signs. The court instead found intentional use of use mark 1 on identical designated goods, increasing confusion with target mark 3, and thus an improper-use cancellation ground.
The operative order annulled the IPTAB decision in case 2023 Dang 1893; it did not itself finally cancel the registration. Use mark 1 and target mark 3 were sufficient to establish the ground, so the court did not determine the claimant’s remaining arguments.
Brand changes after registration also require review
The practical lesson is to manage the registration and marketplace presentation together. Simplifying a logo, changing letters or choosing packaging colours calls for considering both departure from the registration and movement towards another trader’s sign. The combined visual impression can be missed if mark and packaging are assessed separately.
A favourable pre-registration opposition decision does not guarantee the same outcome for a new form of use. Here, the opposition also evidenced awareness of the competing signs, while website photographs and prices evidenced trademark use.
Minor changes do not invariably lead to cancellation. This outcome reflected the retained dominant element, movement towards the competing lettering, colour and packaging, identical goods, Korean market recognition and intent in combination. Post-registration changes should be assessed in their actual competitive context.
The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material.
