NEWS & INSIGHTS

When must consent to trademark coexistence be obtained? The Syotpeul refusal case

Korea’s Patent Court upheld the refusal of the Syotpeul application: consent obtained after the administrative appeal decision could not establish that decision’s illegality.

Case cover showing documents and a clock, illustrating consent before the IPTAB decision in 2026He10195

Consent from the owner of an earlier trademark may resolve a conflict, but its timing matters. In judgment 2026He10195 of 14 October 2026, Korea’s Patent Court considered whether consent obtained during litigation could overturn an earlier decision upholding refusal of the Syotpeul application.

The Syotpeul application and the two earlier registrations

Hana Tour Co., Ltd. filed Korean trademark application No. 40-2023-145315 on 11 August 2023 for a composite sign comprising a figurative element and the Korean wording Syotpeul. The application designated five downloadable software goods in Class 9, concerning content sharing, editing and tracking, and analysis of viewers’ responses. The designated goods define the goods for which trademark protection is sought.

Application No. 40-2023-145315: purple and turquoise geometric elements beside Korean Syotpeul lettering
Applied-for composite mark Syotpeul — Korean application No. 40-2023-145315

The cited rights belonged to Shopl & Company: service mark registration No. 175463 and trademark registration No. 1524192. The service mark combined ShoPl with Korean wording pronounced Syopeul and covered services including retail of computer software. The other registration consisted of the word shopl and covered various software goods.

Service mark registration No. 175463: blue and orange ShoPl lettering above its Korean wording
Earlier service mark ShoPl with Korean wording — registration No. 175463
Trademark registration No. 1524192: shopl in black lowercase letters
Earlier word mark shopl — registration No. 1524192

The examiner refused registration on 25 October 2024 because of similarity to the earlier marks. Hana Tour challenged the refusal before Korea’s Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB), which dismissed the appeal on 28 April 2026 in decision 2024Won2437. This administrative appeal is the procedure for asking the IPTAB to reconsider the examiner’s refusal.

The proprietor’s consent came after the IPTAB decision

Hana Tour obtained the earlier proprietor’s consent to registration of the applied-for mark on 18 June 2026. In the subsequent court proceedings, it argued that consent had removed the refusal ground based on the earlier registrations. The consent nevertheless postdated the IPTAB’s decision of 28 April 2026.

The proviso to Article 34(1)(7) of the Korean Trademark Act, as discussed in the judgment, provides an exception where the owner of the conflicting earlier registration consents to registration. Consent concerning an identical mark used for identical goods is excluded from that exception. In this context, consent means the earlier proprietor’s agreement to registration of the other applicant’s mark.

Legality was assessed at the date of the IPTAB decision

Where refusal has been challenged through an administrative appeal, the court explained, the relevant date for determining registrability is the date of the IPTAB decision. That date applies both to the existence of a conflict with an earlier registration and to the availability of the consent-based exception.

An action to cancel an IPTAB decision examines whether that administrative decision was lawful. The assessment therefore concerns the law and factual circumstances existing when the decision was made. A fact arising only afterwards cannot establish that the earlier decision was unlawful.

For the exception to apply in this case, consent had to have been obtained before the IPTAB issued its decision. Consent given on 18 June did not retrospectively make the decision of 28 April unlawful. Obtaining consent during litigation is different from showing that consent already existed at the relevant decision date.

A fresh filing date and intervening applicants also mattered

The court explained that, where a new circumstance removes a refusal ground only after the IPTAB decision, the ordinary course is to file a new application. A fresh application carries a new filing date. A third party that filed an identical or similar mark between the original and new filing dates may therefore rank ahead of the new application.

Allowing later consent to overturn the earlier decision while preserving the original filing date would unfairly favour an applicant pursuing litigation over one following the ordinary refiling procedure. It could also undermine the expectations of third parties that filed after consulting the public examination and appeal records.

The judgment does not mean that late consent can never have any effect. It means that this consent could not justify cancelling the existing IPTAB decision in this action. A new application would require consideration of its new filing date and the other registration requirements; consent alone would not guarantee registration.

Different appearances did not overcome similar Korean pronunciations

Hana Tour also argued that the signs were dissimilar even without the consent exception. The court accepted that their appearance differed because of the figurative element, the number of characters and their arrangement. It also examined how consumers would pronounce the signs.

The rectangular elements in the applied-for mark had no particular verbal designation, so consumers would primarily call it Syotpeul. The earlier service mark would be called Syopeul, following its accompanying Korean wording. The word mark shopl could be pronounced Syopeul or Syapeul by Korean consumers.

The court noted that Syotpeul and Syopeul each have two Korean syllables. The first syllables share their initial consonant and vowel, and the second syllables are identical. The presence or absence of a final consonant in the first syllable was insufficient to distinguish the overall sound of the marks.

The expressions were coined terms without dictionary meanings, so no particular concepts could be compared. Hana Tour argued that they referred respectively to short videos and a place where show hosts and other talented people gather. The evidence did not establish that the relevant trade generally used those meanings or that the words directly described the designated goods or services.

The parties did not dispute the similarity of the software-related goods and services: their production, distribution and sales channels, and their consumers, overlapped. Despite the visual differences, the court considered the similar pronunciation capable of causing confusion about commercial origin. It upheld the refusal ground and dismissed Hana Tour’s action to cancel the IPTAB decision.

Practical lessons from the timing of consent

When a consent-based resolution is being explored, negotiation and appeal timetables should be managed together. The applied-for mark, earlier rights, covered goods and actual date of consent should be clearly identified in the supporting record. These are practical observations drawn from the judgment’s treatment of timing.

A decision to refile should not assume that the original filing date can be retained. The new filing date and intervening third-party applications need to be considered. Clearance work should examine Korean and Latin wording and actual pronunciation as well as the logo’s appearance.

The Syotpeul case distinguishes obtaining consent from overturning an existing refusal decision. The analysis must address what circumstances existed when the IPTAB decided the appeal, rather than stopping at the fact that consent was eventually obtained.

The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material.

Read the Korean source

This article reflects the information available when it was published. Contact us to discuss your circumstances.
Discuss this topic ↗All articlesRelated service: Designs & trade marks ↗ Related service: IP disputes & appeals ↗

Put your IP strategy into practice.