
A shared word does not automatically become the dominant part of several trademarks. Nor does a foreign winery’s long history, without supporting market evidence, necessarily establish the recognition required to invalidate a later Korean filing.
The Korean Patent Court dismissed the invalidity claimant’s cancellation action on 20 March 2025 in case 2024Heo14322. The challenged Korean-language mark, rendered here as “Le Bourgeois,” remained unaffected by the grounds advanced.
Three different earlier signs required separate analysis
Korean registration No. 1649684 was filed on 26 May 2020 and registered on 7 October 2020 for services including wine bars, pubs, restaurants and sommelier services. The claimant relied on MOULINS BOURGEOIS for flour and bread, a composite CRU BOURGEOIS mark for wine, and the previously used Les Bourgeois Vineyards sign of a Missouri winery.
The first two were earlier registered marks; the winery’s foreign use raised a distinct statutory ground. Evidence relating to one could not simply establish the status of another.



The common word was not independently dominant
Under Article 34(1)(7), the marks were compared in appearance, sound and meaning as a whole. MOULINS and BOURGEOIS appeared in the same size and style. The French dictionary meaning of “moulins” did not show that Korean consumers would disregard it. Packaging sometimes emphasized BOURGEOIS alone, but other examples used the complete name.


In CRU BOURGEOIS, the prominent initials, graphic arrangement and wine-related expression worked together. The record did not justify treating the shared word as the sole dominant component of either mark.
Different overall impressions disposed of the registered-mark ground
The Korean mark and the earlier signs differed in script, graphic composition and pronunciation, including their opening elements—Le, Moulins and Cru. Their additional concepts also differed.
Because the marks themselves were not similar, the court did not need to decide similarity between the designated goods and services. The decision should not be read as a general finding that wine and restaurant services are unrelated.
Foreign use required recognition and an improper purpose
Article 34(1)(13) can protect a mark recognized as indicating another person’s goods in Korea or abroad. The relevant inquiry included recognition at the filing date and an improper purpose in the later filing.
The winery’s history, website, activities, encyclopedia entry and awards showed that it operated and used the sign, but did not establish the necessary recognition by 26 May 2020. Nor was there evidence of negotiations or a relationship between the parties supporting the alleged improper purpose.

Build the evidential record around the relevant date
A foreign business should collect dated sales, distribution areas, advertising expenditure and audience reach, together with evidence linking recognition to the particular sign. General publicity or longevity is not a substitute for that connection.
For shared-word arguments, examine how consumers encounter the complete marks and whether the common element truly stands out independently. Keep the registered-mark comparison and foreign prior-use theory separate, with evidence supporting each requirement.
The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material.
