
A patent enforcement measure can ultimately fail without having been wrongful when taken. Case 2024Na10881 illustrates the importance of the decision then in force, the information communicated to customers and the sequence of later events.
On 22 May 2025, the Korean Patent Court dismissed the importer’s appeal, leaving in place the Seoul Central District Court’s judgment of 20 June 2024 in case 2022Gahap548397.
A detention based on an existing scope decision
The defendant company’s chief executive held two patents. A September 2019 tribunal decision had found the identified product within claim 1 of the first patent. When 932 imported units arrived in May 2020, Incheon Customs notified suspected infringement; the company requested detention and provided security of KRW 25,930,000.
Detention began around 14 May. Release was notified on 22 October and clearance completed on 26 October 2020. In September, the Patent Court had overturned the scope decision because the technology was free to work; that judgment became final on 12 November, after the goods had been released.
Later reversal did not automatically prove fault
Liability under Articles 389(3) and 210 of the Commercial Act required examination of intentional or negligent misconduct in the chief executive’s duties. The court considered the favorable scope decision available when detention was requested in May, rather than judging that request solely by the later result.
Separate invalidity proceedings also had to be distinguished: a correction was allowed and the remaining challenged claims were not held invalid. An alleged second detention request was not established merely by a customs notice referring to another patent.
What the warning letters actually said
A May 2022 letter to a customer sought cessation of sales and disposal of products on the basis of likely infringement of claim 1 of the second patent. It referred to a supporting tribunal decision and disclosed that cancellation proceedings were pending.
Other August warnings concerned a soymilk production method and porridge-making equipment in different proceedings. The evidence did not establish false assertions or improper pressure sufficient to make those communications unlawful.
Unsuccessful proceedings and abuse of rights
Later unsuccessful trials or criminal proceedings did not, without more, establish abuse. The court took account of the initial favorable decisions and of the immediate withdrawal of the Trade Commission investigation request after reversal of the second scope decision.
The holding is evidence-specific. It does not grant immunity for inaccurate warnings, continued enforcement after the foundation disappears, or requests made without a reasonable technical and legal basis.
Maintain a dated enforcement record
A rights holder should preserve the claim comparison and decision relied upon, describe pending appeals accurately, and reassess the measure when a new ruling arrives. Statements about one patent should not be attributed to another without evidence.
An importer seeking compensation should identify the detention request actually made, its timing, the resulting storage or business loss, and what the requester knew at that time. A later favorable judgment alone does not establish every element of liability.
The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material.
