# A customer’s design change request did not make it a joint creator

A vehicle-panel dispute separates a general placement request from concrete visual creation and examines pre-filing sales under the historical grace-period rule.

Source: https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963

HOME / NEWS & INSIGHTS NEWS & INSIGHTS A customer’s design change request did not make it a joint creator A vehicle-panel dispute separates a general placement request from concrete visual creation and examines pre-filing sales under the historical grace-period rule. Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.15 published IPLEX 5 min read Commissioning a product or requesting a functional change does not necessarily make the customer a creator of its design. The contribution must reach the concrete appearance rather than merely the project’s objective. In case 2021Heo2595, decided on 19 November 2021, the Korean Patent Court dismissed the action challenging the rejection of invalidity for design No. 904571. The dispute also concerned pre-filing disclosures and combinations of earlier designs. The development record In June 2016 the defendant and customer F arranged molds for a front grille and a number-plate mounting panel, rather than the plate itself or an entire bumper. D, a co-representative of the defendant, prepared a draft on 21 June. F asked that the plate sit below the grille instead of on it, and D revised the design on 8 July. F supplied no specific drawing or detailed shape instructions. The application was filed on 25 August 2016 and registered the following year. Two application reference views of the registered panel A general instruction was not joint creation The right to obtain design registration belongs to the creator or successor. A general requirement about function or position is insufficient without a concrete contribution to the overall visual appearance. The drawings and revisions supported D’s creative role. The parties’ agreement placed the intellectual property with the defendant while allowing F free use. Restrictions on making molds for third parties and F’s role in selling the products did not establish that F was a creator or owner. Earlier customer publicity and the applicable six-month period Car-club group-purchase photographs appeared on 6, 23 and 24 August, and F posted a video on 11 August, before filing. The court treated the relevant earlier designs 1–4 as disclosures falling within the historical six-month novelty exception; compliance with the procedural claim requirements was not disputed. Earlier disclosure photographs numbered 1–3 Earlier disclosure video image numbered 4 The creator had transferred the right to the defendant. The disclosures therefore did not establish lack of novelty or easy creation against this application. The six-month period describes the law applicable to this older filing, not a statement of today’s period. The remaining references did not supply the overall appearance Earlier designs 5–7 shared a long rectangular form and a V-shaped bend associated with a bumper or plate mount. Those basic functional features carried limited weight. The registered panel combined three rectangular front recesses, an H-shaped rear projection and an upper slope steeper than the lower slope. Comparison with earlier panel designs 5–7 References 8–13 concerning fastening grooves did not provide that combination. Even if the rear could be adapted from familiar fixing structures, they did not explain the three front recesses and differentiated slopes as a whole. The easy-creation challenge therefore also failed. Rear structures and fastening references 8–13 Separate the brief, the visual contribution and the rights Keep dated drafts and records identifying who proposed the actual shape, rather than relying on the customer’s commercial role or payment alone. Agreements should distinguish permission to use molds from the right to obtain registration. Record the earliest sale, customer post or video together with its source and the relevant rights transfer. A disclosure exception depends on the applicable filing date, the origin of disclosure and the required procedural steps. The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material. Read the Korean source This article reflects the information available when it was published. Contact us to discuss your circumstances. Discuss this topic ↗ All articles Related service: Designs & trade marks ↗ Related service: IP disputes & appeals ↗ ON THIS PAGE The development record A general instruction was not joint creation Earlier customer publicity and the applicable six-month period The remaining references did not supply the overall appearance Separate the brief, the visual contribution and the rights TALK TO IPLEX Discuss your IP questions We consider your technology and business needs together. ↗ Contact us Newer FrugalGPT: use answer scores to decide when another model is worth calling ↗ Older NK365: a business partner’s filing role did not establish sole ownership ↗ Related insights Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.19 Trainer designs: why stitching and sole details changed the result A Korean invalidity dispute examined whether known shoe features could readily yield the registered design’s particular overall appearance. ↗ Read article Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.19 NO MORE PIZZA: the same words can play different roles A Korean trademark judgment distinguished a dominant brand element from supporting slogan-like wording in a composite mark. ↗ Read article Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.18 A recessed socket design: the hidden rear still matters A Korean design judgment considered the whole socket, including surfaces visible during sale but concealed after installation. ↗ Read article

- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/category/trademark
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/ko/blog/brunch-case-1963
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/trademark#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/disputes#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963#article-1963-en-0
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963#article-1963-en-1
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963#article-1963-en-2
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963#article-1963-en-3
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1963#article-1963-en-4
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/frugalgpt-answer-scoring-model-cascade
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1962
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1977
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1977
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1976
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1976
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1973
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1973
