# Online sales and reviews as evidence of trade mark recognition

Korean Patent Court case 2025Heo10296 examines prior use, online reviews, advertising and bad faith in refusing a COCINA application for shower products.

Source: https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951

HOME / NEWS & INSIGHTS NEWS & INSIGHTS Online sales and reviews as evidence of trade mark recognition Korean Patent Court case 2025Heo10296 examines prior use, online reviews, advertising and bad faith in refusing a COCINA application for shower products. Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.12 published IPLEX 5 min read An application for a shower-product mark may encounter an earlier user even after the applicant has overcome an initial refusal. Registration searches alone may not reveal the significance of the name already used in the market. In case 2025Heo10296, decided on 30 October 2025, the Korean Patent Court upheld a refusal concerning signs pronounced “Kosina” in Korean. It assessed consumer recognition through sales, reviews and advertising, together with the applicant’s purpose. A second refusal after publication of the application On 24 August 2020, the applicant sought registration of a mark combining COCINA with its Korean rendering. The designated Class 11 goods included water-saving showers, shower heads and filters for shower heads. Applied-for mark: COCINA above its Korean spelling The initial refusal relied on similarity to another registered mark. After the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board overturned it, the application was published for opposition. A company already using the Kosina signs opposed, prompting a second refusal under Article 34(1)(13) of the Korean Trademark Act. The Board rejected the applicant’s challenge to that refusal. Publication had therefore not resolved every possible objection to registration. Recognition of the earlier signs and the applicant’s purpose Article 34(1)(13) requires examination of whether, at the filing date, consumers in Korea or abroad recognized the earlier-used mark as identifying a particular commercial source, and whether the applicant intended to use an identical or similar mark for an improper purpose. The earlier company used a combined Kocina/Korean sign, a Korean word mark and a stylized Roman-letter sign. Earlier-used marks 1–3: combined Roman/Korean sign, Korean word sign and stylized Roman lettering Although lettering and arrangement differed, the signs shared the Korean pronunciation Kosina. Identity or similarity of the signs was not disputed between the parties. The main questions were therefore the earlier signs’ recognition when the application was filed and whether the applicant sought to benefit from the goodwill attached to them. Reading sales and advertising evidence together The earlier company had used the signs in online product names and packaging since 2016. Four shower listings reviewed by the court showed 15,347, 1,282, 3,177 and 6,306 reviews. The record also included promotion requests from 2016–2018, a 2019 annual advertising contract and advertising analysis, and purchase reviews posted from 2017 to around May 2020, before the application. Online shower listings showing the Kosina name and 15,347, 1,282, 3,177 and 6,306 reviews Some signs used in practice were stylized or differed slightly in Roman spelling. Their appearance remained very close to the earlier-used signs and their Korean pronunciation was the same. The court could therefore consider those uses when assessing recognition. The appearance of a company name or another product name alongside the sign did not, by itself, negate its use as a trade mark. September 2019 advertising analysis: banners and signs for Kosina bathroom products The court also explained that this provision does not require the earlier-used mark to be registered or the respective goods to be identical or similar as a formal prerequisite. Advertising expenditure for related goods bearing the same mark was consequently not excluded merely because those goods were not showers. The evidence was evaluated as a connected record of market exposure, not as isolated review totals. The survey, bad faith and the result In the applicant’s 2022 survey, 299 of 1,011 respondents said they had seen or heard the earlier signs. The court lacked information about the sample’s age, gender and regional distribution and would not accept its objective statistical value at face value. Consumers need not know the exact company name to recognize a consistent commercial source; the roughly 30% response could instead support recognition alongside the other evidence. For improper purpose, the court considered the shared pronunciation, the designation of showers and shower heads already sold under the earlier signs, and the applicant’s experience of multiple filings and refusals. It also noted that the explanation of the name in the original application differed from the account of independent creation advanced in court. Together, these circumstances supported an intention to take advantage of the earlier signs’ reputation or business goodwill. The Patent Court dismissed the applicant’s action, finding the Board’s conclusion under Article 34(1)(13) lawful. This was a challenge to a second refusal before registration, not a case invalidating an already registered COCINA application mark. Practical preparation before filing or defending prior use Clearance should extend beyond registered marks to products actually sold in the relevant market. Small differences in Roman or Korean spelling may leave the pronunciation unchanged. Reviewing how similar names are used for relevant goods can reveal conflicts before an application is filed. To demonstrate recognition, link product pages and packaging photographs with ordering records, advertising and the dates of customer reviews. A review count alone is not a legal threshold. The useful record shows which sign was used on which goods, where consumers encountered it and how that exposure relates to the filing date. The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material. Read the Korean source This article reflects the information available when it was published. Contact us to discuss your circumstances. Discuss this topic ↗ All articles Related service: Designs & trade marks ↗ Related service: IP disputes & appeals ↗ ON THIS PAGE A second refusal after publication of the application Recognition of the earlier signs and the applicant’s purpose Reading sales and advertising evidence together The survey, bad faith and the result Practical preparation before filing or defending prior use TALK TO IPLEX Discuss your IP questions We consider your technology and business needs together. ↗ Contact us Newer Cutting-board designs: why the notch-and-hook combination mattered ↗ Older Can new evidence support a second patent invalidation petition? ↗ Related insights Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.19 Trainer designs: why stitching and sole details changed the result A Korean invalidity dispute examined whether known shoe features could readily yield the registered design’s particular overall appearance. ↗ Read article Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.19 NO MORE PIZZA: the same words can play different roles A Korean trademark judgment distinguished a dominant brand element from supporting slogan-like wording in a composite mark. ↗ Read article Designs & Trademarks 2026.11.18 A recessed socket design: the hidden rear still matters A Korean design judgment considered the whole socket, including surfaces visible during sale but concealed after installation. ↗ Read article

- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/category/trademark
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/ko/blog/brunch-case-1951
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/trademark#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/disputes#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951#article-1951-en-0
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951#article-1951-en-1
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951#article-1951-en-2
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951#article-1951-en-3
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1951#article-1951-en-4
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1952
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1950
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1977
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1977
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1976
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1976
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1973
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1973
