# Inventive step in a seat-belt retractor: why removing a component was not enough

Korea’s Supreme Court rejected a hindsight-based combination of seat-belt references, examining their purposes, component functions and the effects of the complete assembly.

Source: https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905

HOME / NEWS & INSIGHTS NEWS & INSIGHTS Inventive step in a seat-belt retractor: why removing a component was not enough Korea’s Supreme Court rejected a hindsight-based combination of seat-belt references, examining their purposes, component functions and the effects of the complete assembly. Patents & Utility Models 2026.11.02 published IPLEX 6 min read A prior-art device may resemble an invention if one component is removed and others are borrowed from separate documents. That reconstruction alone does not establish obviousness. Korea’s Supreme Court explained why in judgment 2024 Hu 10641 of 15 January 2026, concerning a seat-belt retractor. The corrected retractor claims and the appeal The patent sought a simpler, more compact retractor incorporating a tensioning device and a load limiter. The dispute concerned claim 1 and dependent claims 3–7 as corrected by the IPTAB decision of 16 February 2022 in case 2022 Jeong 10. The Board had rejected the invalidation request. Korea’s Patent Court then found the claims to lack inventive step and set aside the Board’s decision in judgment 2022 Heo 6297 of 13 June 2024. The patentee appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal required more than a list of known parts. The court examined whether a person skilled in the art, using knowledge available at the filing date, could readily arrive at the particular combination and its effects without first knowing the patented solution. Removing the second tensioner changed the prior art’s premise Prior art 5 addressed interference with belt payout when electric and pyrotechnic tensioners were used together. It placed the electric tensioner and locking mechanism on one side, and the pyrotechnic tensioner on the opposite side so that both systems could operate together. Corrected claim 1 instead placed the tensioner on the same side as the locking mechanism, with no other tensioner on the opposite side. The lower court considered that deleting the pyrotechnic tensioner from prior art 5 would bridge this difference. The Supreme Court disagreed. Deletion disregarded the reference’s particular technical problem and the significance of its two-tensioner arrangement. Prior art 5 did not even identify the patented objective of simplification and miniaturization. The completed invention could not be used as a blueprint for rewriting the reference. The conditional omission in prior art 10 Prior art 10 did state that its first pretensioner could be omitted. But it also explained that omission upset the left-right balance and recommended an emergency locking mechanism. The omission sentence could not be detached from those conditions. Restoring the balance or incorporating that locking mechanism would require substantial redesign. The accompanying teaching could therefore discourage, rather than motivate, combining prior art 10 with prior art 5. This was not a rule that every combination needs an express instruction in a document. A combination may also be readily apparent from the filing-date level of technology, common knowledge, basic technical problems, development trends and industry needs. The evidence must nevertheless support that reasoning in the particular case. Prior art 9’s pawl performed a different function The lower court mapped prior art 9’s ring, pawl and ratchet teeth onto the claimed housing, lock and teeth. Yet that pawl and those teeth served a load-limiting function. The corresponding locking function was performed by the reference’s separate conventional locking mechanism and ratchet-tooth means. Because the functions differed, the court found no adequate motivation or suggestion for taking the identified load-limiter components and combining them with prior art 5. Similar-looking parts could not be treated as interchangeable merely by giving them matching labels. Prior art 9’s ring contained little beyond the pawl and ratchet teeth. The claim also required the tensioner drive wheel inside the housing, demanding substantial structural redesign. The comparison therefore had to address the functions of the parts and their relationship within the assembly. The outer portion provided stability and retained internal parts The claimed tensioner drive wheel was seated between a first part and the outer portion of a second part. This arrangement could stabilize the wheel during rapid rotation. The outer portion could also act as a stop that kept internal parts from escaping the housing. This retaining role was another concrete effect of the arrangement. Prior art 5 did not disclose a corresponding outer portion. It was consequently difficult to expect the same stabilizing and retaining effects from that reference or to treat this difference as readily overcome. A gearbox was not the claimed enclosing housing The claimed housing was a separate case fixed to the frame. It surrounded and protected the tensioning device, locking mechanism and other internal parts. Its enclosure and sealing could prevent the escape of noise, gas and pyrotechnic material. By contrast, prior art 5’s gear housing was a modular gearbox protecting the electric motor and gears. It did not enclose the external locking components. That gearbox could not prevent noise arising between it and the locking teeth from escaping. The common word ‘housing’ therefore concealed materially different structures, protective boundaries and effects; the difference could not simply be dismissed as routine design. The Supreme Court’s remand and the lesson for inventive-step analysis A multi-element claim must be assessed as an organically combined technical whole. Identifying each part somewhere in the prior art is insufficient: the difficulty of the combination and its particular effects must also be considered without hindsight. The Supreme Court held that prior art 5 combined with prior art 9, prior art 10 and the other cited material did not negate the inventive step of claim 1. The same applied to claims 3–7, which depended directly or indirectly on it. The Court quashed the Patent Court judgment and remanded the case for further consideration; it did not issue an unrestricted declaration of validity against every possible challenge. In practice, explain why a reference includes a component, what conditions accompany its removal, and whether the proposed substitute truly performs the same function. Draw the complete arrangement and identify the effects of component placement and enclosure before concluding that a simpler-looking reconstruction was obvious. The original figure labels and forms are preserved; the text explains the source material. Read the Korean source This article reflects the information available when it was published. Contact us to discuss your circumstances. Discuss this topic ↗ All articles Related service: Patents & utility models ↗ Related service: IP disputes & appeals ↗ ON THIS PAGE The corrected retractor claims and the appeal Removing the second tensioner changed the prior art’s premise The conditional omission in prior art 10 Prior art 9’s pawl performed a different function The outer portion provided stability and retained internal parts A gearbox was not the claimed enclosing housing The Supreme Court’s remand and the lesson for inventive-step analysis TALK TO IPLEX Discuss your IP questions We consider your technology and business needs together. ↗ Contact us Newer A rare surname and a clinic name: distinctiveness of the Gye dermatology mark ↗ Older Exclusive design licences: why the Korean register matters ↗ Related insights Patents & Utility Models 2026.11.19 Narrowing a medical-use claim: what supports the patient subgroup? A Korean linagliptin judgment distinguishes sufficient disclosure of a therapeutic effect from whether use in a defined patient group was inventive. ↗ Read article Patents & Utility Models 2026.11.18 A prior-art defence after a binding finding of literal coverage A Korean louvre patent dispute shows why the binding effect of an earlier judgment matters when a scope-confirmation case returns to the tribunal. ↗ Read article Patents & Utility Models 2026.11.17 Dish-rack patent infringement: why the court awarded treble damages A Korean dish-rack dispute separates product structure from assembly practice and examines distinct post-amendment sales, intent and enhanced damages. ↗ Read article

- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/category/patent
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/ko/blog/brunch-case-1905
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/patent#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/ip-solutions/disputes#related-insights
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-0
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-1
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-2
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-3
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-4
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-5
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1905#article-1905-en-6
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/contact
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1906
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1904
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1975
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1975
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1971
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1971
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1967
- https://www.iplexlaw.co.kr/en/blog/brunch-case-1967
